I'd like to say that it's been a long, hard road to finally get the layout and functionality of my blog site updated, but it actually hasn't.
If you've been here before, and you're here now, you've undoubtedly noticed that this site is now completely different than how it used to look and function. Finally, I have busted away from the shackles of minimalist, or brutalist, layout and design that I created in 2015. Finally, I have created a new, decent layout that is something more than the barren layout of yesterday. A lot has changed since 2015. Both in my personal life, professional life, and honestly, the entire outer-world.
However, the biggest change was not with the layout of this site, but with what's powering this site. Previously, I used Pelican, a Python-based static blog generator, to build my site, and then upload the changes to my webhost. Pelican worked by taking a directory of markdown files and transforming them into HTML markup, and then slipping that into a bare/basic page template I made. This worked well, outside of remembering the commands to get Pelican to regenerate the the site every few, sparing months I had something to write/post about. But it was always a little bit of a pain. Launching Terminal.app. $ cd'ing to the right directory. Activating the virtual environment...
I'd actually thought about giving the whole setup up, and returning as others have to something like wordpress or a traditional CMS.
The downside is... well, security and keeping everything updated. And the mess of dealing with a RDBMS on the server, keeping that secure and updated. I was baseline-tepid about the prospects of that.
A few weeks ago, I discovered the concept of the flat-file CMS while browsing around developer/tech sites. People posted about three strong flat-file CMS contenders.
All three of them look great. And the thinking behind them is genius. With more functionality than a command-line static blog generator (like Pelican) or a crazy-heavy RDBMS CMS (like wordpress), these flat-file CMSes fall somewhere in between. The store their data in a series of files in a directory structure on the file system, and then magically pull it all to life, doing the transforms from markdown to (HTML) markup on page-load (with caching, to be sure). But they also include, in some cases, really slick admin interfaces.
The first of these CMSes that I looked into was Kirby. Their admin interface looks great and polished, the featureset looks strong and honestly, it just has a really positive vibe about it. It does cost for a license, which, to me is not a mark against it, as it might be to others. I have no problem paying people for their hardwork in creating polished and well-built pieces of software or software solutions.
Next, I looked at Grav. As you might guess from the title of this post, this is the flat-file CMS I chose to use to rebuild this website. Like Kirby, Grav is polished and has a great feature-set. Grav, from my initial impressions, also looked to be a bit more powerful and developable than Kirby is. The futher I looked into Grav, the more enamored I became. Not only did it have a great admin interface, it also came with, or had available, a handful of incredibly useful plugins.
The Pros of Going Grav:
- No database needed!
- PHP-based, which is one of the most preverse server-side runtimes of all time.
- Config files for IIS, Apache and NGINX.
- Stores page data in markdown files.
- Slick admin interface.
- Forms plugin, which allows you to create public forms for site visitors, and forms in the admin section to add custom fields to your page types. Form data is stored in each page's "frontmatter."
- Hireachicial templating system that is powered by Twig (Twig is my favorite).
- Ability to create SQL-esque queries in both the page's "frontmatter" and inside of the template file itself to get just the data you need.
- Page frontmatter is editable via the admin interface. No need to open a text editor or SSH your way to your remote server.
- Seems really open for customization and development, if you need to extend it in any way (CMS event hooks, etc.).
- Taxonomies: categories and tag. And they are queryable too!
- Easy to check the entire site/project in to source control since all the the data/content are stored in files. Now even your content can be versioned!
- Pretty good and illustrative documentation.
- Completely free!
The Cons of Going Grav:
- Currently, there is no way to edit forms visually via the admin section (which is really a plugin). You need to hand-edit YAML files (which isn't hard, but might not be considered accessible to those who aren't technically savvy). This is being worked on, from what I have read, and will likely be part of a paid version of the admin plugin. If you're used to things like Gravity Forms or the Umbraco Forms plugin, non-developers will miss the editor interface.
- A little more developer-centric (in general) than what I saw in my curosry glance at Kirby with the YAML config files.
- Only has markdown support. If you need a WYSIYG editor in the admin section, right now Grav won't work for you. The current editor does have clickable buttons to help guide you along, but you are literally writing and seeing markdown text/content. The Grav team posted that they were working on adding this capability to the paid-admin plugin, but were having difficulties getting consistent and reliable results with translating between actual WYSIYG markup and the markdown format that the files are stored in.
- Figuring out how the quries work and learning YAML can be a small barrier to getting stuff done, but you'll work yourself over it.
In general, I LOVE Grav. Seriously, kudo's to the Grav team. I can't tell them how much I love what they have created and how nice and refreshing it has been to use (especially after wordpress monoculture took over the world).
I also considered Lektor, which looks like another great option from what I saw. The bad thing is that I become so attached to Grav that I haven't yet given it a spin and don't really have any sort of analysis on it yet (maybe in a future post).
Grav is a CMS that I truly feel as though I can build great sites with. It makes great choices, it gets out of your way, and yet it's still remarkably powerful in what it lets you do. For any of you out there reading this post, Grav is great and I highly recommend downloading it and putting together a demo site.